IBI Magazine

Outdated Hiring Strategy?

Change Your Approach, Get Better Results

Brunswick ad 5
Brunswick ad 2
Brunswick ad 4
Brunswick ad 1
Brunswick ad 3

Hiring right now can feel like treading water. Two small businesses in the same market can have completely different staffing situations: one scraping by, the other fully staffed. That gap isn’t about talent, it’s about approach.

I’ve visited centers where owners say there just aren’t any good employees around, then walked into a nearby restaurant and had excellent service. The talent exists. The question is whether we’re doing what it takes to attract it.

Hiring today is a lot like fishing, you need the right pond, the right bait, and a reason for people to bite.

Hiring Has Changed

The old “Now Hiring” sign and a generic job post don’t cut it anymore. A starting wage that hasn’t moved in years won’t either. Today’s employees are looking beyond pay. They want flexibility, communication, and to feel valued.

I recently spoke with a young employee who left one job for another in the same industry at the same pay. The difference was better scheduling, more notice, and a sense that the company actually wanted him to grow.

Adjust to Today’s Expectations

Work expectations have changed and holding onto “how it’s always been done” creates a disconnect. The shift to understanding what works with today’s teams, and adjusting to meet those expectations, is one of the most impactful changes a manager can make.

It doesn’t cost anything—but it does require intention.

Recruiting Is Marketing

Recruiting is marketing now. Your job posting is an ad. Your social media can be a recruiting tool, and your employees are your billboard. Think about how you sell a birthday party. You highlight the experience and how it feels. Now apply that to hiring. You’re selling a job to someone who has options.

Someone once told me, “Fish where the fish are.” If your target hire is on TikTok and you’re posting on a bulletin board, you’re not fishing in the right pond. And once you find the right pond, you still need the right bait.

Focus your recruiting efforts on:

  • Platforms your target employees actually use
  • Employee referrals and word-of-mouth
  • Job posts that highlight experience, not just duties
  • Showing your culture, not just describing it

Key takeaway: If candidates aren’t coming to you, your message or placement is off.

Pay Matters But It’s Not Everything

Pay matters, but it’s often not why people stay or leave.

What matters just as much:

  • Schedule flexibility
  • Clear communication
  • Feeling respected and treated like an adult
  • Opportunities to learn and grow

Even in centers with limited advancement, you can create growth by teaching new skills, like hosting parties, working in food service, or learning basic maintenance. And don’t forget to make work fun!

Culture Is An Investment

Many operators say they can’t afford incentives or bonuses. I’d argue you can’t afford not to. Replacing an entry-level employee costs 30–50% of their annual salary, and more for skilled roles. That doesn’t include the impact on guest experience when turnover is high.

Your best tool is word-of-mouth. If your workplace is positive, employees will tell others. If it’s not, they’ll share that faster. One operator started a simple weekly team huddle where recognizing staff, sharing wins, and asking what would make the week better all created a culture of inclusion. Hiring improved, and employees started bringing in friends.

Start Small, But Start Now

You don’t need to overhaul everything. Start with one change this week.

Simple ways to begin:

  • Revisit your last job posting—would you apply?
  • Have one real conversation with an employee and listen
  • Improve scheduling communication
  • Recognize a team member publicly

Small moves, made consistently, add up. The centers that succeed will be the ones that understand their people are the product.

And if you want to catch better fish, it’s about making your pond the place they want to be.

Kids Bowl Free: turn slower times into more revenue. Bring in families, increase spending, build your customer database. Learn more.
Kids Bowl Free: discover why over 1,360 bowling centers are raving about the Kids Bowl Free summer bowling program. Learn more.

Latest from IBI

Is Your Website Doing Its Job?

The Real Cost

Clear Feedback